The 5 Best Date Night Restaurants in West Chester, PA

It only takes one date to lay the foundation for a loving relationship that lasts a lifetime. If you pick out the right date night restaurant in West Chester, PA, the possibilities are endless. There are many date night restaurants across the borough. But here’s a look at five of the most popular date night restaurant options in West Chester.  

1. Andiario

Andiario on West Gay Street offers upscale dining at its best.  

The menu at Andiario changes weekly and is inspired by the season. Depending on when you visit, you may be able to choose from duck ragu, wood-roasted beef neck with buttered cabbage, and many other delectable dishes. Meanwhile, Andiaro offers an open kitchen, so you and your date can chat about your respective meals as you watch the chef prepare them right in front of your eyes.

Among the date night restaurants in West Chester, PA, Andiario is highly exclusive. The restaurant begins accepting reservations at noon on the 20th of the current month for the next month (for instance, reservations for December at Andiario open at noon on November 20). 

Dinners at Andiario are $80 per person. A wine list is available, with a corkage fee of $35 per bottle. Guests can also purchase beer and cocktails and access wine pairings with each dinner at varying costs. Along with these things, you’re welcome to BYOB.    

“It’s not a ‘restaurant’…it’s an art studio! It’s not dining, it’s a culinary experience! It started when we made the reservation and continued with entering the elegantly decorated room and finished when we left highly impressed.” – Heinrich Botes

2. Greystone Oyster Bar

Want to impress your date with seafood? Stop by Greystone Oyster Bar on North Church Street to sample some of the best seafood in West Chester.

Greystone offers fresh, high-quality seafood. The restaurant’s raw bar menu includes oysters from Massachusetts, Long Island, and even Canada. There are also oyster shooters like the Fresca and Cowboy that make it easy to level up your raw bar experience. To pull out all of the stops on your date, Greystone’s seafood tower of shrimp, oysters, and other types of seafood is an excellent choice.

If you or your date prefers drinks over seafood, visiting Greystone is still worth the trip. Greystone offers an assortment of refined cocktails and craft beers. The restaurant provides a comfortable, cozy atmosphere where you and your date can enjoy drinks, chat, and get to know each other better.

“This place! Finally got a chance to go and I’m filled with regret – regret that it took me this long to experience Greystone and all the excellence that abounds here! The atmosphere reminds me of one of those classy, hip Manhattan seafood joints, the service was on point…and the food! From the impressive FRESH oyster selection to the fish that’s cooked/seasoned just right…  Do yourself a favor and stop in to Greystone. If you don’t find it pretty close to perfection, head and shoulders above anything else in the area, I don’t know what to tell you.” – Michael Boggs 

3. The Original Spence Cafe

Since 1996, The Original Spence Cafe has brought life to the West Chester food scene. It’s also been a top spot for first dates, blind dates, anniversary dates, and many others.

Spence Cafe offers classic American meals and seafood dishes. From spring lamb ravioli to filet mignon, there’s something for everyone on the café’s entrée menu. Or, if you and your date believe sharing is caring, you can enjoy tuna tartare, crispy “boom boom” shrimp, or one of the other café’s shared plates. And, after your meal, you and your date can treat yourselves to any of the café’s mouthwatering house-made seasonal desserts. 

You have the option to dine indoors or out on the patio (weather permitting) at Spence Cafe. The restaurant is open Wednesday through Saturday, and reservations are recommended.

“Absolutely amazing dining experience! The Original Spence Cafe is a gem, truly. We loved everything from start to finish – appetizers to dessert. Portions were outstanding. Every dish was cooked and prepared to perfection.” – Bethany Bones

4. Stove & Tap

For a dynamic dining experience, bring your date to Stove & Tap on West Gay Street. Stove & Tap strives to be more than just a great restaurant. To achieve its goal, Stove & Tap offers a food menu that uses the freshest, locally sourced ingredients. On top of that, the restaurant provides an exciting date night atmosphere that blends big flavor with a big personality.

The food menu at Stove & Tap includes rustic American favorites like brisket mac and cheese and tap fries. There are also soups, salads, burgers, tacos, flatbread pizzas, and other delicious menu options. As far as drinks go, Stove & Tap’s got you covered. Stove & Tap offers awe-inspiring cocktails like the Notorious F.I.G. and strawberry lemon drop martini that will stir up conversations between you and your date. It also provides a wine menu with many white, red, and sparkling options.

“One of West Chester’s finest just gets better like a glass of fine wine! So much variety at great value. The food is as delicious as it looks and the portion sizes are impressive. A great date spot or family dinner — it’s equally worth it!” – Ernest Owens

5. Gemelli

Skip the dinner date and go straight to dessert at Gemelli on West Market Street. Here, you and your date can break the ice over authentic Italian gelato. Gemelli is an artisanal gelato dessert café that brings a taste of Italy to West Chester. It offers seasonal, farm-fresh gelato that ranks among the world’s best.  

In addition to gelato, you and your date can indulge your sweet tooth with chocolate mousse, tiramisu, and other jaw-dropping Italian desserts at Gemelli. There’s also gourmet coffee or tea drinks to enjoy.

“Best gelato I’ve ever had (better than places I’ve been to in Italy). Chocolate is my favorite. First tried Gemelli in a cake and had to come back the next day. Cozy interior with plenty of seating. Signage inside touts locally sourced, high quality ingredients – it’s clear in the product. Just delicious. Highly recommend!” – Ursula V

The Bottom Line on the Best Date Night Restaurants in West Chester, PA

Let’s face it — planning a date can be stressful and exhausting. Lucky for you, there are many terrific West Chester, PA, restaurants at your disposal. If you can’t decide between the best restaurants in West Chester, PA for your next date, local real estate agent Mike Ciunci can help you. Mike knows all about the best West Chester restaurants. He can teach you about the top restaurants near West Chester, PA, and all they offer. Of course, if you want to buy or sell a house in West Chester, Mike’s happy to help you in any way possible, too.

Contact Mike Ciunci to buy or sell a home in West Chester, PA.